I was looking for an "everyday lipstick" and this formula provides just that: a lipstick that has good pigmentation (yet not as strong as the "true velvet") and yet is very comfortable to wear the whole day. The color range has certainly something for everyone, I was looking for a "almost nude" shade, and was doubing between the colors "Lisa" and "Ashes of Roses". I went for Ashes of Roses and although I do like the color, it looks a bit darker than I was expecting. Will be trying the shade "Lisa" in the next opportunity.
The packaging is very glamourous and looks fabulous, but I have the impression you need to be very careful closing it, making sure you really closed it properly. Quite a different feel if you compare with the True Velvet packaging, which has magnets.
So for me the lipstick deserves 5 stars, but the packaging only 4.